Hey guys, I need some recommendations for rulesets. I have always played 1:1 scale wargames, but I want to go bigger now. I’m looking for a set of platoon scale (or larger) that has a good balance between detail and quickness of play. I know that GHQ’s Micro Armor is platoon scale, and so is GDW’s Combined Arms, but I have no experience with either of them. Has anyone played them both? Are there any other rules out there for modern at this scale? Solo playability is a plus.
I would even go bigger in order to play a division-level game if I could. I have a set of rules called NATO Division Commander that uses battalion-level counters on a map. Maybe I could use those rules for supply and movement up to a battle and then throw battalion sized units of micro armor on the terrain board to fight the engagement.
Seeking Rules Recommendations
Moderators: dnichols, GHQ, Mk 1
-
redleg
- E5
- Posts: 3809
- Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 11:02 am
- Location: Riverside, CA
-
BenfromBrooklyn
- E5
- Posts: 149
- Joined: Mon Mar 20, 2017 10:57 pm
- Location: New York City
FFT3
I use Fistful of Tows with some home grown modifications.
Overall, I like it.
The good: Simple and yet comprehensive, the game does not drag. Lots of data available. The 1 miniature = 1 platoon scale faithfully mimics the fight as seen from a brigade or battalion TOC, where individual vehicles would never be posted on the SITMAP. It allows a brigade or battalion size battle in a reasonable area.
The bad: A few rules need tweaking, I feel. The "A 6 always hits" rule leads to a very unrealistic "If I already need a 6 it can't ever get worse" system. If a unit already needs a 6, it can be suppressed, gassed, in the middle of the night without any night vision... nothing will affect it, still needs a 6. The 1 miniature =5 vehicles rule is a little clunky, I find everything works better if you set 1 miniature = 3.5 vehicles. Yes, it will give some (mostly Western) formations an "extra" vehicle, but this is realistic in a Western unit and adds to their flexibility. Plus, FFT3's own Order of battle pages seemsto have gone this way, in part- a Russian infantry company with 10 or 11 vehicles still gets 3 miniatures, not 5.
Something I would like to see but I don't know how without complicating things too much: I would like to see a game in which miniatures represent platoons, but the platoons can have levels of damage instead of 100%, Suppressed, or Dead.
Overall, I like it.
The good: Simple and yet comprehensive, the game does not drag. Lots of data available. The 1 miniature = 1 platoon scale faithfully mimics the fight as seen from a brigade or battalion TOC, where individual vehicles would never be posted on the SITMAP. It allows a brigade or battalion size battle in a reasonable area.
The bad: A few rules need tweaking, I feel. The "A 6 always hits" rule leads to a very unrealistic "If I already need a 6 it can't ever get worse" system. If a unit already needs a 6, it can be suppressed, gassed, in the middle of the night without any night vision... nothing will affect it, still needs a 6. The 1 miniature =5 vehicles rule is a little clunky, I find everything works better if you set 1 miniature = 3.5 vehicles. Yes, it will give some (mostly Western) formations an "extra" vehicle, but this is realistic in a Western unit and adds to their flexibility. Plus, FFT3's own Order of battle pages seemsto have gone this way, in part- a Russian infantry company with 10 or 11 vehicles still gets 3 miniatures, not 5.
Something I would like to see but I don't know how without complicating things too much: I would like to see a game in which miniatures represent platoons, but the platoons can have levels of damage instead of 100%, Suppressed, or Dead.
-
rdenman62
- E5
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Sun Jul 09, 2006 5:35 pm
- Location: Michigan
Modern Spearhead is pretty good. Just do a search for it. Its platoon based. I really like the
command and control part of the rules.
The next one I would recommend but its geared towards one to one is called "Seven days to the Rhine". I just picked up a set and they do look quite interesting. Have not played them yet so cannot speak on how well they flow. They do have videos on youtube to explain the play.
command and control part of the rules.
The next one I would recommend but its geared towards one to one is called "Seven days to the Rhine". I just picked up a set and they do look quite interesting. Have not played them yet so cannot speak on how well they flow. They do have videos on youtube to explain the play.
Peace thru superior firepower
-
Steel Arrows
- E5
- Posts: 115
- Joined: Wed Jun 01, 2005 12:10 pm
- Location: Los Angeles, CA
-
Hoth_902
- E5
- Posts: 1537
- Joined: Wed Jun 18, 2014 11:08 am
- Location: Pacific Northwest
- Contact:
Burtwolf,
I believe Fist Full of TOWs III does play well for WWII. I have not played it yet, but here is a video that uses the rule set.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUpXo9i8K6U
The Game report looked like it worked well.
I believe Fist Full of TOWs III does play well for WWII. I have not played it yet, but here is a video that uses the rule set.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUpXo9i8K6U
The Game report looked like it worked well.