US Sherman 1943
Moderators: dnichols, GHQ, Mk 1
-
dougeagle
- E5
- Posts: 726
- Joined: Thu Mar 23, 2006 10:07 am
- Location: Northern Alberta
US Sherman 1943
Which Sherman (75mm) would be the main Sherman used in the Normand Campaign in 1944...the M4A1 or M4A3?
Doug
A goal is not always meant to be reached, it often serves simply as something to aim at.
Bruce Lee
A goal is not always meant to be reached, it often serves simply as something to aim at.
Bruce Lee
-
dougeagle
- E5
- Posts: 726
- Joined: Thu Mar 23, 2006 10:07 am
- Location: Northern Alberta
Awesome. I do have another question though. The Sherman M4 (76mm) with cast hull, would it be better to use it for the Normandy Campaign or would the M4A3 (76mm) be better?Vergeltungswaffe wrote:M4 and M4A1 at the time of Normandy. M4A3 become the most numerous variant around autumn 1944.
Doug
A goal is not always meant to be reached, it often serves simply as something to aim at.
Bruce Lee
A goal is not always meant to be reached, it often serves simply as something to aim at.
Bruce Lee
-
pmskaar
- E5
- Posts: 2175
- Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2005 5:45 am
Shermans
Hi Doug
I do not consider myself t the resident expert on Shermans - Mk1 is more knowledgeable on some of the specifics. Here is what I do know from previously checking out th
is very thing out for myself and listening to others including Mk1.
Basically what Vertgeltungswaffe said is true of the 75mm Shermans. For the 76mm Sherman at the time of the Cobra breakout, the M4A1 w. 76 would be the one. The M4A3 w. 76 showed up later in the Autumn.
I hope that with the new later model M4A1 that GHQ is doing that they will start to address the Shermans in Normandy. I would also like to see them do an M4 for this time period as well and maybe a redo of the M4A1 76mm.
Pete - Binpicker, Out!
I do not consider myself t the resident expert on Shermans - Mk1 is more knowledgeable on some of the specifics. Here is what I do know from previously checking out th
is very thing out for myself and listening to others including Mk1.
Basically what Vertgeltungswaffe said is true of the 75mm Shermans. For the 76mm Sherman at the time of the Cobra breakout, the M4A1 w. 76 would be the one. The M4A3 w. 76 showed up later in the Autumn.
I hope that with the new later model M4A1 that GHQ is doing that they will start to address the Shermans in Normandy. I would also like to see them do an M4 for this time period as well and maybe a redo of the M4A1 76mm.
Pete - Binpicker, Out!
-
pmskaar
- E5
- Posts: 2175
- Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2005 5:45 am
Shermans
Hi Doug
I do not consider myself t the resident expert on Shermans - Mk1 is more knowledgeable on some of the specifics. Here is what I do know from previously checking out this very thing out for myself and listening to others including Mk1.
Basically what Vertgeltungswaffe said is true of the 75mm Shermans. For the 76mm Sherman at the time of the Cobra breakout, the M4A1 w. 76 would be the one. The M4A3 w. 76 showed up later in the Autumn.
I hope that with the new later model M4A1 that GHQ is doing that they will start to address the Shermans in Normandy. I would also like to see them do an M4 for this time period as well and maybe a redo of the M4A1 76mm.
Pete - Binpicker, Out!
I do not consider myself t the resident expert on Shermans - Mk1 is more knowledgeable on some of the specifics. Here is what I do know from previously checking out this very thing out for myself and listening to others including Mk1.
Basically what Vertgeltungswaffe said is true of the 75mm Shermans. For the 76mm Sherman at the time of the Cobra breakout, the M4A1 w. 76 would be the one. The M4A3 w. 76 showed up later in the Autumn.
I hope that with the new later model M4A1 that GHQ is doing that they will start to address the Shermans in Normandy. I would also like to see them do an M4 for this time period as well and maybe a redo of the M4A1 76mm.
Pete - Binpicker, Out!
